Risk Management Magazine

Search for Articles

Stupid Hurts

Stupid Hurts

We've had a number of motorcyclist fatalities in our little town, and I suspect that it’s the same story all across America. I’m sad for the families of the deceased riders, but I’m angry that so many motorcyclists put themselves in danger. The prevailing attitudes among motorcyclists seem to be that “anyone can do it” and “no special skills are needed.” People who are otherwise prudent about life seem willing to hop on a motorcycle and zoom off into traffic with almost no practice or study.

Our latest victim was an off-duty police officer who was riding with some friends on a Sunday afternoon. She was 27 years old, popular and at the prime of her career. According to the state patrol, her motorcycle failed to negotiate a right curve. “The motorcycle crossed the centerline and struck the right front bumper of a southbound pickup truck that was towing a boat trailer,” the state patrol said. “The rider was pronounced dead at the scene.” The newspaper article about the accident notes that her bike was a 2004 Yamaha, but it said nothing about her licensing status or experience level.

Later in the week, headlines read, “Police bid a solemn farewell.” A procession of about 50 police and emergency vehicles delivered the flag-draped coffin to the high school auditorium for a memorial service where hundreds of mourners honored her memory.

I’m sure that no one in our community would want to hear that she might have done it to herself, but in the case of many self-inflicted fatalities, that’s the sad truth. Her friends all made the corner — she didn’t. A motorcycle going wide in a turn is an indication the rider didn’t know how to corner. And since the bike was less than a year old, we know that she hadn’t had much experience with that machine — and we might suspect she hadn’t been motorcycling very long. It’s entirely possible she had never learned to countersteer, or had heard about it but never gotten it between her ears.

Did her friends know she was inexperienced, but assumed that she would absorb the necessary skills by just getting out and riding? Did any of her riding buddies explain cornering techniques to her, suggest taking a training course or loan her copies of books that might have expanded her knowledge and skill? We don’t know. The tears are flowing now that she’s dead, but apparently there wasn’t enough concern when she was still alive and struggling to figure out how to control her motorcycle.

Recently I was driving my SUV out of the hardware store parking lot. The lot is two lanes in at the east end and two lanes out at the west end. It’s a two-lane street with a center turn lane. At the exit, I observed a motorcycle approaching from the west, but the rider gave no indication he might be turning. Then as I started to pull out, he suddenly darted into the center turn lane and leaned into a left turn. Halfway into the street, I braked to a stop. He circled around in front of me and rode into the exit. No signal, no braking and no concern that a collision with a 4,000-pound truck might hurt. Also, no acknowledgment that he was going the wrong way or that I had braked to avoid hitting him.

I bring up this example of “asking for it” because the world is full of drivers who are not concerned about motorcycles, and therefore motorcycles do not register on their mental radar. This rider could just as easily have turned in front of an inattentive driver, and the impact could have been fatal. And of course, the following week there could have been another memorial service with tears and quavering speeches about how he loved motorcycles and what a great father he had been.

When I first started riding, I felt motorcyclists who crashed were victims of something out of their control. With more experience, I realized that many riders did it to themselves. One day I was in line for the signal light, waiting to pull out onto the main highway. A rider in street clothes zipped by me on the wrong side of the road and attempted to carve off on a side road, oblivious to the white lines being covered in dew. His tires slid out, the bike low-sided and he slid along for a few feet, sanding off bits of shoes and clothing. Fortunately, it was a slow-speed crash.

The surprised rider picked himself up with a shocked expression, staring at his bloody palms. I didn’t stop to assist; I just motored on when the light turned green. I wouldn’t have been sympathetic. I’d probably had said, “Who do you think you are — Superman? If you aren’t hurt, I’ll give you a couple of healthy kicks in the ass with my steel-toe boot to further your education.”

Stupid riding ticks me off
What angers me about stupid riding is that it’s unnecessary. Why risk your life riding on public roads before you learn how to corner? Why risk your life just to get into a parking lot a few seconds sooner? I suppose the answers include motorcyclists not knowing how to control a motorcycle proficiently, not understanding what danger looks like or just not being aware that motorcycles require considerable knowledge and skill.

Back up again to that left-turning motorcyclist at the hardware store. His riding tactics really sucked. He didn’t help the situation by sudden moves without signaling, or riding into an exit rather than going down to the marked entrance. More importantly, he didn’t seem to recognize that SUVs are much more hazardous to motorcyclists than are smaller vehicles. If you slam into the side of a Civic or Corolla, the thin metal will absorb a lot of energy as it crumples, and you’ll probably go sailing over the top to slide down the pavement. But if you slam into a truck-based SUV, it’s not going to bend much, and it’s too tall to clear. So there’s a good chance you’ll bash your body into the side.

To put it another way, the riders I’ve mentioned shared the sin of not understanding what danger looks like or what to do about it. They were basically deficient on mental skills. So, how do we expect such riders to get smarter? I’ve written two books on street riding skills, “Proficient Motorcycling” and “More Proficient Motorcycling.” I occasionally offer articles (such as this one) for posting in publications.

I’ve also offered seminars at various rallies, where we can discuss riding skills. After one seminar a couple of years ago, a participant came up and said, “Dave, you know there was not one question in the seminar that you haven’t already answered in your books.” I explained that humans have different learning styles. Some people can learn by reading. Others have difficulty. Some people can only learn by talking about something, others only by trial-and-error. That’s why it’s important to have books, seminars and training courses. We need a variety of learning opportunities to match the variety of different adult learning styles.

At the Sportbike Northwest rally this summer, I did a seminar on cornering tactics for public roads. Some riders participated; others made a point of sitting nearby and talking loudly among themselves. Was a seminar needed for a group of apparently experienced sport riders? Well, during the event, several of those “experienced” riders managed to crash. Is there any relationship between those who ignore information and those who crash? Could it be that even experienced riders could learn some little tidbit that might help avoid a crash?

Emergency avoidance skills

The Motorcycle Safety Foundation has always been big on emergency avoidance maneuvers, especially braking and swerving. Their original concept was to figure out what accident-involved riders were doing wrong and then teach the missing skills. The MSF courses were heavily influenced by results of the Hurt Report that showed a high percentage of riders crashing into cars without taking any evasive action. Ergo: “Let’s teach ‘em to do emergency swerves and quick stops.”

That made sense to me as a new instructor back in 1980, but eventually I realized that we couldn’t depend on emergency maneuvers. The human brain is wired so that in an emergency we react based on habits, and then think about it later. In other words, if you’re dumb enough to not brake for an SUV that’s about to turn across your path, your habits will determine what happens next. If you’re in the habit of just rolling off the gas, you’ll slow down gradually, right up to impact. If maximum effort braking is a no-brainer for you, you might do an aggressive quick stop. And if you’re in the habit of not braking once you’re committed to a turn, you’ll motor ahead. The point is you won’t squander time on thinking. You’ll just do it.

That’s why I suggest finding some twisty road and riding it aggressively so you’ll make powerful steering and braking inputs part of your habit patterns. If you live out in the flatlands where there aren’t any good twisty roads, you could practice cornering and braking skills in a controlled situation such as a cornering range.

There is a practice cornering range in More Proficient Motorcycling that’s been painted down in various locations around the country. The Idaho State Police are using it for officer training. Team Oregon follows the same idea, but they use a go-kart track. Personally, I think rally participants would gain skill quickly by riding such a cornering range. Or, perhaps your local club could find some pavement and set it up. There are detailed instructions for lying out and running the PM Cornering Range in the book.

So what’s important? Skills or knowledge?

The emphasis on emergency skills in training courses has led us to believe that control skills are where we should focus. Certainly, it’s important to know how to corner, how to shift gears without sliding the rear tire, how to brake hard without falling down. But eventually, most of us realize that what’s really important is to know what trouble looks like and how to avoid riding into it.

A young, bulletproof rider might have the reflexes to ride dumbly into bad situations and then survive with split-second maneuvers. Nine out of 10 they make it. But long-term survival demands that we look further ahead, spot potential problems early and just make small adjustments in line or speed to avoid a dangerous situation.

Frankly, if you’re still experiencing lots of close calls, you’re not using your brain enough. If you don’t spot a driver about to turn left until he’s smack in front of you, it means you weren’t paying enough attention to traffic around you. If you come over a hill and suddenly have to brake hard to avoid a truck backing out of a driveway, that means you were riding too fast for your sight distance at the moment. It’s important to spot dynamic patterns that could lead to a collision and take action soon enough to get out of the way. Veteran riders typically have few close calls because they have developed proficient mental skills.

There are a number of other riding skills books available by well-known motorcycle racers, including Nick Ienatsch, Keith Code and Reg Pridmore. These track-oriented books are helpful for fast cornering, but that’s also the drawback. They are focused primarily on track skills rather than riding on public roads. Whitehorse Press has reworked the MSF’s book, “Motorcycling Excellence,” into a second edition that now includes tidbits of advice by various famous road racers, plus some traffic scenarios by an author you’ll probably recognize. This is a good book to give to any new riders in your circle of friends. It might help them avoid a fatal accident while they’re figuring it all out.

Please, let’s get smarter about riding on public roads. Stupid hurts.

  • 1 September 2013
  • Author: Army Safety
  • Number of views: 7123
  • Comments: 0